17 Criminal Investigator Interview Questions and Answers

Learn what skills and qualities interviewers are looking for from a criminal investigator, what questions you can expect, and how you should go about answering them.

Crime scene investigators, also known as criminal investigators, are the first responders to crime scenes. They are responsible for collecting and preserving evidence, interviewing witnesses, and preparing reports. They work closely with law enforcement to identify suspects and bring them to justice.

If you want to work as a criminal investigator, you’ll need to be able to answer questions about your investigative experience and knowledge during a job interview. In this guide, you’ll find criminal investigator interview questions and answers that will help you stand out from the competition.

Are you comfortable working in potentially dangerous situations?

Criminal investigators often work in dangerous situations, so employers ask this question to make sure you are comfortable with the risk. In your answer, explain that you understand the risks of this job and can handle them. You can also mention any training or experience you have working in these types of situations.

Example: “Yes, I am very comfortable working in potentially dangerous situations. Throughout my career as a police officer, I’ve worked many late-night shifts when there were fewer people on the streets. This means I was more likely to encounter someone who was committing a crime. I always made sure to stay alert and prepared for anything. I feel like I have the skills necessary to keep myself safe while doing my job.”

What are the most important qualities for a successful criminal investigator?

Employers ask this question to learn more about your personality and how you would fit in with their team. They want someone who is honest, hardworking, empathetic and organized. When answering this question, think of a few qualities that are important to you and explain why they’re beneficial for criminal investigators.

Example: “I believe the most important quality for a successful criminal investigator is empathy. It’s important to be able to understand what victims and suspects are going through so we can do our best to help them. I also think it’s important to have strong communication skills because we often work as part of a team. Finally, I think it’s essential to be detail-oriented since we need to gather evidence and write reports.”

How do you conduct an interrogation?

Interviewers may ask this question to assess your interviewing skills. They want to know how you conduct an interview and what techniques you use to get information from a suspect or witness. In your answer, explain the steps you take when conducting an interrogation. Explain that you are empathetic and try to make the person feel comfortable during the process.

Example: “I start by introducing myself and explaining why I am there. Then, I tell them they have the right to remain silent and that anything they say can be used against them in court. After that, I begin asking questions about the incident. I try to be as empathetic as possible while still getting the answers I need. I also try to keep my voice calm so that it is not intimidating.”

What is your process for collecting evidence?

This question can help the interviewer understand how you approach your work and what methods you use to complete it. Your answer should include a step-by-step process for collecting evidence, including which tools or resources you use to do so.

Example: “I first assess the scene of the crime by looking at all available sources of information. I then collect any physical evidence that may be present, such as fingerprints, DNA samples, blood stains and more. After this, I take photographs of the scene and write down my observations. Finally, I transport the evidence back to the lab where I analyze it further.”

Provide an example of a time when you had to use your communication skills to resolve a conflict.

As a criminal investigator, you may have to communicate with witnesses and suspects. Employers ask this question to make sure your communication skills are strong enough to help you succeed in the role. When answering this question, think of a time when you had to use your communication skills to resolve a conflict or disagreement. Try to choose an example that shows how you can be empathetic and respectful while still getting your point across.

Example: “When I was working as a police officer, I responded to a call where a man was threatening his wife. He was yelling at her and telling her she wasn’t allowed to leave the house. She told me that he was drunk and didn’t mean what he said. I talked to him calmly and asked him why he was so upset. He explained that he was worried about money and wanted to know if she spent any of their funds on shopping.

I listened to everything he had to say and tried to reassure him that she would never do anything like that. After talking for a few minutes, he calmed down and apologized to her. They both agreed to go to counseling together.”

If you were investigating a crime committed by a group of people, how would you identify and interview all of the suspects?

This question can help interviewers understand your investigative skills and how you would approach a challenging case. In your answer, try to explain the steps you would take to identify all of the suspects involved in the crime and how you would conduct interviews with each person.

Example: “I would first use my knowledge of criminal investigation techniques to find evidence that links everyone together. For example, I might look for similarities between their clothing or vehicles to see if they were all at the same location at the time of the crime. Then, I would contact each suspect individually and ask them questions about their whereabouts during the crime. If any of them have conflicting stories, I would continue to investigate until I could determine who was telling the truth.”

What would you do if you suspected a fellow investigator was tampering with evidence?

This question can help the interviewer assess your ability to work with others and how you would handle conflict. Your answer should show that you value teamwork, respect authority and are willing to report misconduct when necessary.

Example: “I have worked in law enforcement for five years now, and I’ve never had a situation where an investigator was tampering with evidence. However, if I ever suspected someone of doing so, I would first approach them privately to discuss my concerns. If they were unwilling to change their behavior, I would report it to my supervisor or other senior member of the department.”

How well do you know the criminal justice system?

The interviewer may ask this question to see how familiar you are with the criminal justice system and its processes. This can be an important skill for a criminal investigator, as they must understand the laws of their jurisdiction and know how to navigate the court system. In your answer, try to show that you have a strong understanding of the criminal justice system and what it takes to work within it.

Example: “I’ve been working in law enforcement for five years now, so I am quite familiar with the criminal justice system. I know how each department works together to solve crimes and prosecute criminals. I also know how to navigate the court system, which is essential when gathering evidence and preparing cases.”

Do you have any experience with forensics?

Criminal investigators often need to use forensics, or the application of scientific methods and procedures in criminal investigations. Employers ask this question to see if you have any experience with forensics and how much you know about it. If you do have experience with forensics, share a specific example of when you used it. If you don’t have experience with forensics, explain what forensics is and give an example of when you applied science to solve a problem.

Example: “I have some experience with forensics. In my last position as a detective, I had to investigate a case where someone was stealing money from their employer. We found that the employee’s computer was infected with malware that allowed someone else to access the company’s financial records. Using forensics, we were able to find out who planted the malware on the computer.”

When conducting an investigation, how do you determine who to interview and question?

Interviewers may ask this question to learn more about your investigative process. They want to know how you make decisions that affect the outcome of an investigation and whether you can effectively work with others on a team. In your answer, describe the steps you take when deciding who to interview or question during an investigation.

Example: “When determining who to interview or question, I first look at all available evidence. This helps me determine which individuals are most likely involved in the crime. Next, I consider any leads or tips my team has gathered from other sources. Finally, I decide which individuals I will interview based on their proximity to the crime scene, their relationship to the victim or suspect and their access to relevant information.”

We want to improve our response time to emergency calls. How would you improve our response time?

This question is an opportunity to show your problem-solving skills and ability to work with a team. Your answer should include how you would improve the response time, who you would involve in the process and what resources you would use.

Example: “I would first analyze our current response times by looking at call logs and dispatch records. I would then meet with my supervisor to discuss possible solutions. One solution we could implement is using GPS tracking on all emergency vehicles so dispatchers can see where each vehicle is located. This will help them know when to expect a certain unit to arrive at the scene of the crime. Another solution is hiring more criminal investigators to reduce the amount of cases each investigator has.”

Describe your experience with using databases and other digital tools to investigate crimes.

Criminal investigators use a variety of tools to gather information about suspects, victims and witnesses. Employers ask this question to make sure you have experience using these tools and can adapt to their specific database system if they use one. In your answer, explain which digital tools you’ve used in the past and what challenges you faced while using them. Explain how you overcame those challenges or what steps you would take to learn new systems quickly.

Example: “In my last role as a criminal investigator, I worked with our department’s proprietary database system. While it was helpful for organizing all of our case files, I found that it didn’t allow me to search for certain keywords very easily. To overcome this challenge, I learned how to use Boolean logic to narrow down my searches. This helped me find important details within cases more efficiently.”

What makes you stand out from other candidates for this position?

Employers ask this question to learn more about your qualifications and how you can contribute to their team. When answering this question, it can be helpful to highlight a skill or experience that makes you unique from other candidates. You may also want to mention any skills you have that are relevant to the job.

Example: “I am passionate about helping others, which is why I became a criminal investigator in the first place. In my previous role as a police officer, I was able to solve many cases by listening carefully to what witnesses had to say. This helped me develop strong communication skills that make me an excellent candidate for this position.”

Which law enforcement agencies have you previously worked with?

This question is a great way for employers to learn more about your experience and background. When answering this question, it can be beneficial to list the agencies you’ve worked with in the past and what role you had there. It’s also important to mention any awards or commendations you may have received while working at these agencies.

Example: “I’ve previously worked as a criminal investigator for both the New York City Police Department and the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Office. I was awarded the Medal of Valor from the LAPD for my work on a case involving an armed robbery that took place at a local convenience store. The sheriff’s office recognized me for my outstanding work ethic and dedication to solving cases.”

What do you think is the most important aspect of completing a criminal investigation?

This question is an opportunity to show your interviewer that you understand the importance of a criminal investigation and how it can impact the lives of those involved. When answering this question, consider what skills or qualities you have that make you a good investigator.

Example: “I think the most important aspect of completing a criminal investigation is gathering evidence in a timely manner. Evidence can be crucial to proving someone’s guilt or innocence, so I always work quickly but carefully when collecting evidence at a crime scene. In my last role as a criminal investigator, I was able to gather enough evidence within two hours of arriving at the scene of a robbery to arrest the suspect.”

How often do you complete criminal investigations?

Employers ask this question to learn about your experience with criminal investigations. They want to know how often you complete these types of cases and what kind of results you’ve had in the past. When answering this question, it can be helpful to mention a specific case or two that you remember well. This can help show employers that you have experience working on these kinds of cases.

Example: “In my current role as a private investigator, I usually complete one criminal investigation per month. These are typically missing persons cases where clients hire me to find their loved ones. In my previous position as a police officer, I completed an average of three criminal investigations per week. Most of these were for theft or other property crimes.”

There is a conflict between your findings and those of another investigator on the same case. How do you handle it?

This question is a great way to assess your ability to work with others and collaborate on projects. It also shows the interviewer how you handle conflict in the workplace. In your answer, try to show that you can be diplomatic and respectful of other people’s opinions while still maintaining your own conclusions.

Example: “I would first ask my colleague why they came to their conclusion. I would then explain my reasoning for reaching my conclusion. If we both have valid points, I would suggest we meet again after researching more about the case. This helps us avoid making any rash decisions and allows us time to find additional evidence.”


17 Machinist Interview Questions and Answers

Back to Interview

17 Geologist Interview Questions and Answers