25 Major Gifts Officer Interview Questions and Answers

Learn what skills and qualities interviewers are looking for from a major gifts officer, what questions you can expect, and how you should go about answering them.

A major gifts officer is responsible for securing donations from individuals and organizations that are above a certain threshold. In order to be successful in this position, you need to be able to cultivate relationships with potential donors and persuade them to give.

Before you can ask for a donation, you need to be able to answer some questions about the organization you want to donate to. In this guide, you will find questions and answers about the role of a major gifts officer.

Common Major Gifts Officer Interview Questions

1. Are you familiar with the tax laws that apply to charitable giving?

The interviewer may ask this question to assess your knowledge of the laws that apply to major gifts fundraising. This is because you will likely need to know how much donors can deduct from their taxes when they make a donation to your organization. Showcase your understanding of these tax laws by explaining what information you would share with potential donors about them.

Example: “Yes, I am familiar with the tax laws that apply to charitable giving. During my time as a Major Gifts Officer, I have gained extensive experience in this area. I understand how to properly document donations and ensure compliance with applicable regulations. I also stay up-to-date on any changes in the law so that I can provide donors with accurate information about their potential deductions.

In addition, I have developed strong relationships with local attorneys and accountants who specialize in philanthropic matters. This allows me to provide donors with reliable advice when it comes to making sure their gifts are properly documented for tax purposes. Finally, I have a thorough understanding of the various types of gift vehicles available to donors, such as trusts, annuities, and bequests, and can help them make informed decisions about which vehicle best meets their needs.”

2. What are some of the most effective strategies you’ve used to cultivate a major gift?

This question can give the interviewer insight into your fundraising strategies and how you plan to use them in their organization. Use examples from past experiences that highlight your ability to cultivate major gifts, such as:

Example: “I have had success cultivating major gifts through a variety of strategies. One of the most effective is to build relationships with potential donors and establish trust. I like to start by getting to know them on a personal level, learning about their interests and passions. This helps me understand what motivates them and how they might be willing to give.

Once I’ve established a relationship, I focus on creating an engaging presentation that outlines the mission of the organization and how the donor’s gift could make a difference. I also provide detailed information about the impact of their donation and how it will benefit the community. Finally, I follow up regularly to ensure that the donor feels valued and appreciated for their contribution.”

3. How would you approach a donor who has consistently donated small amounts?

This question can help the interviewer assess your ability to engage with donors and encourage them to increase their donations. Use examples from previous experience or discuss strategies you would use to approach a donor who has donated small amounts in the past.

Example: “When approaching a donor who has consistently donated small amounts, I believe it is important to first thank them for their generosity and express appreciation for their commitment to the organization. It is also important to recognize that every donation, regardless of size, helps further the mission of the organization.

I would then explain how their donations have made an impact on the organization and share stories about how their contributions have helped us reach our goals. This will help build trust with the donor and show that we value their support.

Next, I would discuss ways in which they can increase their giving and explore potential opportunities for larger gifts. I would also be sure to provide information about planned giving options such as endowments or other long-term investments. Finally, I would stay in touch with the donor through regular updates and invitations to events so that they remain engaged with the organization.”

4. What is your experience with using data to inform your fundraising decisions?

Major gifts officers often use data to inform their decisions about which prospects to pursue and how much money they can raise from each prospect. Your answer should show the interviewer that you understand how to analyze data and use it to make informed decisions.

Example: “I have extensive experience using data to inform my fundraising decisions. I understand the importance of analyzing and interpreting data in order to make informed decisions about how best to target potential donors and allocate resources. In my current role, I am responsible for managing a portfolio of major gift prospects and use data to track their giving history, identify trends, and develop strategies for engaging them.

I also utilize data to assess the effectiveness of our donor engagement efforts. For example, I analyze response rates to solicitations, compare results from different campaigns, and look for patterns that can help us refine our approach. This helps me ensure that we are making the most of our time and resources when it comes to cultivating relationships with major donors.”

5. Provide an example of a time when you successfully persuaded a reluctant donor to increase their donation.

Major gifts officers often need to persuade donors to increase their donations. This question helps the interviewer determine how persuasive you are and whether you have experience with this type of task. Use your answer to highlight your communication skills, ability to solve problems and willingness to take risks.

Example: “I recently had the opportunity to work with a donor who was initially hesitant to increase their donation. After doing some research, I discovered that they were passionate about a certain cause and had previously donated to similar causes in the past.

Using this knowledge, I crafted an individualized pitch tailored to their interests and values. During our meeting, I highlighted how their increased donation would make a significant difference for the cause they cared so deeply about. I also provided them with concrete examples of how their contribution could be used to help those in need.

My approach worked! The donor was moved by my presentation and agreed to double their original donation amount. It was incredibly rewarding to see the impact that my persuasive skills had on the donor’s decision. This experience has further solidified my belief that when you take the time to understand a donor’s motivations and tailor your message accordingly, it can lead to successful outcomes.”

6. If a donor made a large gift but then stopped making donations, how would you approach them?

This question can help the interviewer understand how you would react to a challenging situation. It also helps them determine whether your approach is similar to their own and if it aligns with the organization’s values. In your answer, try to explain what steps you would take to ensure that the donor continues making donations while also showing respect for the donor’s wishes.

Example: “If a donor made a large gift but then stopped making donations, I would approach them with respect and understanding. First, I would thank the donor for their generous contribution and express my appreciation for their support of our organization. Then, I would ask if there was anything that we could do to make donating easier or more convenient for them.

I believe in building relationships with donors so I would also take this opportunity to learn more about their interests and motivations for giving. This will help me better understand how to engage them in the future. Finally, I would let the donor know that we value their continued involvement and invite them to stay connected with us through our newsletters, emails, and other communications.”

7. What would you do if you were working on a major gift campaign but the cause suddenly became popular and donations started to decline?

This question can help interviewers understand how you might react to a sudden change in circumstances. They want to know that you have the ability to adapt and find new ways to promote your cause. In your answer, explain what steps you would take to ensure the organization’s success.

Example: “If I were working on a major gift campaign and the cause suddenly became popular and donations started to decline, I would first assess the situation. I would look at the data to determine why donations are declining and what changes need to be made in order to increase them again.

I would then develop a strategy for how to adjust the campaign accordingly. This could involve adjusting the messaging or targeting different audiences that may have more interest in the cause. I would also consider leveraging new technology or resources to reach potential donors.

Ultimately, my goal is to ensure that the campaign remains successful despite any changing circumstances. I am confident that with my experience and expertise, I can create an effective plan of action to get donations back up.”

8. How well do you understand the mission of our organization?

The interviewer may ask this question to assess your knowledge of the organization’s mission and goals. This can help them determine if you’re a good fit for their organization. When preparing for an interview, it can be helpful to read about the organization’s mission statement and recent news articles or press releases. You can also look at the organization’s website to learn more about its history and current projects.

Example: “I understand the mission of your organization very well. I have done extensive research into the goals and objectives of your organization, as well as its history and current initiatives. I am passionate about helping to further your mission and believe that my experience in major gifts can be a great asset to your team.

I have worked with many nonprofit organizations over the years and have developed an understanding of how important it is for them to reach their fundraising goals. My experience has taught me how to build relationships with donors and cultivate long-term support for the organization’s mission. I also understand the importance of creating compelling stories and messages to engage potential donors.”

9. Do you have any experience working with foundations or other large donors?

This question can help the interviewer determine if you have experience working with a specific type of donor. If your previous employer worked with foundations, for example, this can be an opportunity to share what you learned from that experience and how it could benefit their organization.

Example: “Yes, I have extensive experience working with foundations and other large donors. In my current role as a Major Gifts Officer, I am responsible for cultivating relationships with high-level prospects to secure major gifts from individuals, corporations, and foundations.

I have been successful in building strong partnerships with various foundations, including the XYZ Foundation, which has provided generous support for our organization over the past several years. Through my work with this foundation, I have helped to develop and execute fundraising strategies that have resulted in significant contributions to our mission.

In addition, I have also had success in engaging corporate partners to make major donations. For example, I recently secured a $50,000 donation from ABC Corporation for our annual gala event. This was achieved through careful research into the company’s philanthropic goals and objectives, followed by effective communication of our organization’s mission and needs.”

10. When approaching a potential donor for the first time, what is your strategy for building trust?

Major gifts officers often have to approach potential donors for the first time. This question helps employers understand how you plan to build trust with these individuals and get them excited about your organization’s mission. Use examples from past experiences where you’ve successfully built a relationship with a donor or helped someone feel more confident in donating to an organization.

Example: “When approaching a potential donor for the first time, my strategy is to build trust by being honest and transparent. I believe that it’s important to establish an open dialogue with donors from the very beginning so they understand what their donation will be used for and how it will make an impact.

I also strive to create a personal connection with each donor. I take the time to get to know them on a more personal level and learn about their interests and passions. This helps me tailor my approach when discussing our organization’s mission and goals.

Lastly, I always ensure that I am providing accurate information and following through on any promises made. I think this is essential in building trust and establishing a strong relationship with donors.”

11. We want to increase the number of recurring donations we receive. What strategies would you use to accomplish this?

Major gifts officers often need to increase the number of recurring donations they receive. This question allows you to show your ability to develop strategies that can help achieve this goal. In your answer, explain how you would implement a plan to increase the number of donors who give on a regular basis.

Example: “I understand the importance of increasing recurring donations, and I have a few strategies that I believe could help achieve this goal.

The first strategy is to create an engaging donor experience. This includes establishing meaningful relationships with donors through regular communication and updates on how their contributions are making a difference. By creating a positive relationship with donors, they will be more likely to continue donating in the future.

Another strategy would be to use data-driven insights to identify potential donors who may be interested in making recurring donations. Through segmentation, we can target those individuals who are most likely to become repeat donors. We can also utilize social media platforms to reach out to new audiences and increase our visibility.

Lastly, I would suggest offering incentives for recurring donations such as discounts or exclusive access to events. These rewards will encourage donors to commit to giving regularly.”

12. Describe your process for tracking donor information and updating donor records.

Major gifts officers often have to keep track of a lot of information about donors, including their contact information and donation history. This question helps employers understand how you manage this process and whether your methods are effective. In your answer, explain what steps you take when tracking donor information and provide examples of how you’ve used these processes in the past.

Example: “My process for tracking donor information and updating donor records is comprehensive and organized. I start by creating a detailed spreadsheet that includes all relevant donor information, such as contact details, donation history, and any notes or comments about the donor. This helps me to quickly access important information when needed.

I also use customer relationship management (CRM) software to keep track of my donors. The CRM allows me to easily store and update donor data, schedule follow-up calls, and create reports on donor activity. It also helps me stay organized and ensures that no donor is overlooked. Finally, I make sure to regularly review and update donor records in order to ensure accuracy and completeness.”

13. What makes you an excellent candidate for this position?

Employers ask this question to learn more about your qualifications and how you feel about the position. Before your interview, make a list of reasons why you are qualified for this role. Consider including things like:

Your relevant experience Your education Your communication skills Your ability to work with others

Example: “I believe I am an excellent candidate for this position because of my extensive experience in major gifts fundraising. I have been working as a Major Gifts Officer for the past five years, and during that time I have developed a deep understanding of how to effectively identify, cultivate, solicit, and steward major gift donors. My success rate has been consistently high, with many of my campaigns exceeding their goals.

In addition to my professional experience, I also possess strong interpersonal skills which are essential when it comes to building relationships with potential donors. I am highly organized and detail-oriented, so I can easily manage multiple projects at once while still ensuring that each one is completed on time and within budget. Finally, I am passionate about philanthropy and committed to helping organizations achieve their mission through successful major gifts campaigns.”

14. Which fundraising methods do you enjoy the most?

This question can help the interviewer determine your passion for fundraising and which methods you enjoy using. Your answer should reflect a willingness to use multiple methods of fundraising, but it’s important to highlight those that you find most enjoyable or effective.

Example: “I enjoy all aspects of fundraising, but I find that major gifts are my favorite. Major gifts require a great deal of relationship building and understanding the donor’s motivations for giving. It is incredibly rewarding to be able to build relationships with donors and help them achieve their philanthropic goals.

I also appreciate the challenge of developing creative strategies to engage potential major donors. I have been successful in creating unique approaches to connecting with donors, such as hosting special events or leveraging social media platforms. My experience has taught me how to craft compelling stories and messages that will resonate with donors and inspire them to give generously.”

15. What do you think is the most important trait for a major gifts officer to have?

This question is an opportunity to show the interviewer that you have the skills and traits necessary for success in this role. When answering, it can be helpful to mention a trait that you possess and how it helps you succeed as a major gifts officer.

Example: “I believe the most important trait for a major gifts officer to have is excellent communication skills. This role requires building relationships with donors, understanding their needs and interests, and effectively communicating how their donations can help achieve the organization’s goals.

The ability to communicate clearly and confidently is essential in this position. A major gifts officer must be able to articulate the mission of the organization, explain why it’s important, and demonstrate how donations will make an impact. They also need to be able to listen carefully to understand what motivates potential donors and tailor their pitch accordingly.

In addition, strong interpersonal skills are key for success as a major gifts officer. Building trust and rapport with donors is critical in order to secure larger donations, so being personable and having empathy are both important qualities. Finally, having a passion for the cause you’re representing is essential to inspire others to give.”

16. How often do you update your personal fundraising goals?

This question can help the interviewer determine how much initiative you take in your work. It’s important to show that you’re motivated and willing to set goals for yourself, even if they aren’t required by your employer.

Example: “I understand the importance of setting and updating personal fundraising goals in order to stay on track with my professional development. I strive to set realistic, achievable goals that are tailored to my individual strengths and weaknesses. To ensure I am consistently meeting these goals, I review them every quarter. During this review process, I assess how well I have been doing and make any necessary adjustments. This helps me stay focused and motivated while also allowing me to be flexible and adaptable when needed.”

17. There is a discrepancy between the amount of donations you’ve received and the amount you need to achieve your organization’s goals. What do you do?

This question is a test of your ability to prioritize and manage multiple tasks. It also shows the interviewer how you will handle challenges in the workplace. Your answer should show that you are able to work under pressure, plan ahead and communicate effectively with others.

Example: “When faced with a discrepancy between the amount of donations I’ve received and the amount needed to achieve my organization’s goals, I take an analytical approach. First, I look at the data behind the donations that have been made to identify any patterns or trends that could be contributing to the gap. This helps me understand where our current strategy is succeeding and where it may need improvement.

Next, I use this information to develop a plan for increasing donations. This includes researching potential new donors, creating targeted campaigns based on donor interests, and leveraging existing relationships to increase giving. Finally, I track the results of these efforts to ensure that they are having the desired effect. By taking an evidence-based approach to fundraising, I am confident that I can close the gap between donations received and those needed to reach our goals.”

18. Describe a successful major gift solicitation you’ve conducted in the past.

This question is a great way to see how you apply your skills and experience to the job. When answering this question, it can be helpful to describe a specific instance where you were able to successfully solicit a major gift from a donor.

Example: “In my last role as a major gifts officer, I was tasked with soliciting a $100,000 donation from one of our largest donors. The donor had never given us more than $25,000 in any previous donations, so we knew that asking for such a large sum would be challenging. However, I decided to meet with the donor in person to discuss their philanthropic goals and motivations. After spending time getting to know them better, they agreed to give us the $100,000 donation.”

Example: “I recently conducted a successful major gift solicitation for a local nonprofit organization. The goal of the campaign was to raise $50,000 in donations from individual donors.

To begin, I identified potential donors who had previously given large gifts and were likely to give again. I then crafted personalized letters tailored to each donor’s interests and needs. Finally, I followed up with phone calls and emails to ensure that my message was heard.

The results were outstanding. By the end of the campaign, we had raised over $60,000 from individual donors—exceeding our original goal by 20%. This success was due in part to my ability to identify prospective donors, craft persuasive messages, and follow-up diligently.”

19. How do you ensure that our donor base remains loyal to our organization?

Major gifts officers are responsible for maintaining relationships with donors and ensuring they continue to support the organization. Employers ask this question to make sure you have strategies in place to keep their most valuable supporters happy. In your answer, share a few ways you plan to maintain these relationships.

Example: “I understand the importance of donor loyalty and have developed a number of strategies to ensure that our donors remain committed to our organization. First, I believe in building strong relationships with each donor by providing personalized attention and support. This includes responding promptly to their questions and concerns, as well as staying in touch throughout the year.

In addition, I strive to provide meaningful opportunities for engagement with our organization. This can include hosting events or activities that allow them to interact with staff and other supporters, or offering exclusive benefits such as recognition or access to special programs. Finally, I am always looking for ways to thank our donors for their generosity. Whether it’s through an annual report or a simple note of appreciation, I want to make sure they know how much we value their contributions.”

20. Are there any other ways we can leverage our relationships with donors for additional donations?

This question can help the interviewer determine your creativity and willingness to think outside of the box. Use examples from previous experiences where you’ve successfully leveraged relationships with donors for additional donations.

Example: “Absolutely! Leveraging relationships with donors is an essential part of any major gifts officer role. One way to do this is by building a strong relationship with each donor and understanding their individual interests, needs, and giving preferences. This will help you craft tailored messages that are more likely to resonate with them.

Another way to leverage relationships with donors is through events. Hosting events such as dinners or receptions can be a great way to engage with current and potential donors in a meaningful way. It also provides the opportunity for donors to meet other like-minded individuals who may be interested in making donations. Finally, leveraging relationships with donors can be done through personal thank you notes and follow up calls. Acknowledging donors’ generosity and expressing gratitude goes a long way towards strengthening relationships and creating loyalty.”

21. What kind of feedback have you received from your previous employers about your performance as a major gifts officer?

This question can help the interviewer gain insight into your work ethic and how you’ve developed as a major gifts officer. When answering this question, it can be beneficial to highlight any specific skills or abilities that you’ve improved upon since starting in your career.

Example: “I have been fortunate to receive positive feedback from my previous employers about my performance as a major gifts officer. My supervisors have consistently praised me for my ability to build strong relationships with donors and identify potential new sources of funding. They have also commended me on my excellent communication skills, which have enabled me to effectively communicate the organization’s mission and goals to prospective donors. Finally, they have highlighted my success in developing creative strategies to increase donations and maximize donor engagement. I am confident that these same strengths will help me excel in this position.”

22. Can you provide an example of how you’ve used technology and data to improve donor engagement?

Major gifts officers often use data to identify and target potential donors. They also use technology to communicate with current donors, track their progress and measure the success of their fundraising efforts. Your answer should demonstrate your ability to use technology and data to achieve results.

Example: “Yes, absolutely. In my current role as a Major Gifts Officer, I have used technology and data to improve donor engagement in several ways. One example is that I created an automated email system for our major donors. This allowed us to send out personalized messages with relevant information about upcoming events or campaigns. It also enabled us to track the responses of our donors so we could better understand their interests and tailor our outreach accordingly.

Additionally, I implemented a comprehensive CRM system which allowed us to store all donor information in one place and easily segment our audience based on different criteria. This gave us valuable insights into who our most engaged donors were, what kind of content they responded best to, and how we could maximize our efforts to reach them.”

23. Do you have experience creating personalized appeal letters?

Major gift officers often need to write appeal letters that are personalized for each potential donor. This question can help an interviewer determine if you have experience with this type of writing and whether you can do it well. If you have experience, share a specific example of how you did it. If you don’t have personal experience, you can talk about what you would do in this situation.

Example: “Yes, I have extensive experience creating personalized appeal letters. In my current role as a Major Gifts Officer, I am responsible for crafting individualized letters to potential donors. My approach is to create an emotional connection with the donor by highlighting their unique values and interests. I also strive to make sure that each letter reflects the mission of the organization in order to engage the reader.

I understand how important it is to craft compelling and effective appeals that will resonate with potential donors. To do this, I take the time to research each donor’s background and interests so that I can tailor the message accordingly. I also ensure that all letters are well-written and free from errors. Finally, I always follow up with donors after sending out an appeal letter to gauge their response and determine if further action needs to be taken.”

24. How would you respond if a donor expressed concerns about their donation being misused?

Major gift officers often work with donors who have large sums of money to give. These individuals may be concerned about how their donations are being used, and it’s important for major gift officers to reassure them that the organization is using their funds responsibly. When answering this question, explain your process for addressing donor concerns and show that you can maintain a positive relationship with these individuals.

Example: “If a donor expressed concerns about their donation being misused, I would take the time to listen and understand their perspective. It is important to show respect for their opinion and demonstrate that their input is valued. After listening to their concerns, I would explain the organization’s policies and procedures regarding donations, such as how funds are allocated and tracked, and provide assurance that all donations are used in accordance with the donor’s wishes. If necessary, I would also offer to connect them with someone from the organization who could answer any further questions they may have. My goal would be to ensure that the donor feels confident in their decision to donate and that their contribution will be put to good use.”

25. Describe a time when you successfully overcame objections from potential donors.

Interviewers may ask this question to assess your ability to overcome challenges and objections. Use examples from previous work experiences where you had to convince donors to give money to a cause or organization.

Example: “I recently had a successful experience overcoming objections from potential donors. I was working with a large donor who had expressed interest in making a major gift to my organization, but they had some reservations about the impact of their donation. To address this, I worked closely with them to develop an understanding of our mission and how their contribution could help us achieve it.

In order to overcome their objections, I provided detailed information on the specific projects that their donation would fund, as well as the long-term benefits of their investment. I also shared stories of past successes we had achieved through similar donations. This allowed the donor to gain a better understanding of the value of their contribution and made them feel more confident in supporting our cause. In the end, they agreed to make the donation and have since become one of our most loyal supporters.”


25 Appointment Scheduler Interview Questions and Answers

Back to Interview

25 Admissions Counselor Interview Questions and Answers