What is CARR vs ARR: Differences Explained

Subscription-based businesses, particularly those operating under the Software as a Service (SaaS) model, rely on predictable, recurring income streams rather than one-time transactions. This shift requires specialized financial measurements to accurately gauge performance, stability, and long-term potential. Standard accounting metrics often fail to capture the nuances of multi-year agreements, necessitating specific metrics to provide a clear view of the financial trajectory. Metrics centered around the annual value of customer contracts are strong indicators of current operational stability and future growth potential. These measurements are regularly used by management teams and external investors to assess the underlying value of the enterprise.

Understanding Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR)

Annual Recurring Revenue (ARR) is a standardized metric representing the normalized, predictable revenue a company expects to receive over a 12-month period from its active subscription base. This measurement is calculated from revenue that is currently being recognized or billed according to the subscription terms in effect. ARR functions as a snapshot of the company’s current operational size and performance health, showing the revenue generated if the present customer base and pricing remained constant for a full year.

The calculation of ARR is typically derived by multiplying the total Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) by 12. This annualization normalizes monthly billing cycles into a consistent figure for year-over-year comparison and growth tracking. ARR must exclude all non-recurring income streams, such as one-time professional service fees, hardware sales, or non-subscription setup charges, ensuring the figure is purely based on continuous revenue from the core service.

ARR changes only when there is a change in the active customer base or their subscription tier. This reflects new sales that have started billing, customer upgrades (expansion revenue), downgrades (contraction revenue), or cancellations (churn). ARR measures current performance and the effectiveness of the business in retaining and growing existing accounts. It is generally the figure used by financial analysts to benchmark operational efficiency and compare the size of one subscription business to another.

Understanding Contracted Annual Recurring Revenue (CARR)

Contracted Annual Recurring Revenue (CARR) represents the total committed annual value of all signed customer contracts, irrespective of whether the revenue has started being recognized or billed yet. This metric captures the full economic value secured by the sales team, providing a forward-looking view of the revenue stream based on binding contractual commitments. CARR includes future ramp-ups, pre-sold commitments, and contracts that are fully executed but pending an implementation or service start date.

A contract is immediately included in the CARR figure upon its official signing, even if the service does not launch and billing does not commence for several months. This emphasis on the signed agreement makes CARR a powerful tool for tracking the sales backlog and the overall success of the sales pipeline. It specifically tracks the contractual commitment, which is distinct from the current recognized revenue shown by other metrics.

CARR is particularly relevant for businesses dealing with large enterprise contracts that include multi-phase rollouts or delayed start dates. These multi-year contracts often stipulate increasing fees in subsequent years, known as ramp-ups, and CARR captures the full annual value of these future commitments immediately upon contract execution. CARR offers management a clear projection of the predictable revenue that is already guaranteed to materialize in future reporting periods.

Key Differences Between CARR and ARR

The distinction between CARR and ARR fundamentally lies in the timing of revenue inclusion and the specific purpose each metric serves. ARR is based on revenue currently being recognized and billed to active customers, representing the present state of the business. Conversely, CARR is based on the full value of booked and signed contracts, capturing future revenue commitment before it becomes active.

The purpose of each metric also diverges significantly. ARR is used to measure current operational performance, providing a stable figure for financial reporting and benchmarking against peers. CARR, on the other hand, measures future commitment and the success of the sales function in securing long-term contracts. It acts as an indicator of the sales pipeline’s effectiveness and the predictability of the future revenue stream.

The inputs for calculation also differ. ARR relies on active billing cycles and current pricing tiers, reflecting ongoing customer relationships. CARR relies on the total contractual value and the defined start and end dates within the legally binding agreement. For example, if a contract is signed in January but service begins in April, the full annual value is immediately reflected in CARR in January. However, the value is not included in the ARR calculation until April, when billing commences. This time lag is the defining factor separating the two metrics. The difference between CARR and ARR represents the value of contracts that have been sold but not yet activated or implemented.

Why These Metrics Are Crucial for Business Valuation

ARR and CARR are fundamentally important for determining the valuation of subscription-based companies, particularly during fundraising rounds, mergers, and acquisitions. Investors rely on ARR to establish the baseline operational health and current scale of the business, using it to benchmark performance against industry standards and competitors. ARR is a direct reflection of the business’s current operating efficiency and customer retention abilities.

CARR provides a forward-looking dimension to the valuation, offering insight into the predictability and future stability of the revenue stream that is already legally secured. A significant difference between a high CARR and a lower ARR suggests a strong sales backlog and confirmed future growth, often resulting in investors applying a higher valuation multiple. This metric quantifies the success of the sales team and the strength of the pipeline.

The stability and growth trajectory derived from both metrics allow investors to accurately forecast future cash flows and assess investment risk. While ARR confirms the present scale, CARR confirms the contractual momentum. The combination of these two figures provides a comprehensive view of the company’s trajectory, moving beyond historical accounting data to project future financial performance based on signed agreements.

The Foundational Role of Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR)

Monthly Recurring Revenue (MRR) serves as the foundational base unit from which both ARR and CARR are ultimately derived. MRR represents the reliable, normalized monthly income generated from all active subscription agreements. It is a precise measure of financial flow within a short, manageable period, making it a highly sensitive indicator of immediate changes in the customer base.

Tracking changes in MRR is necessary for accurately reporting the annual metrics, as it captures incremental shifts from new sales, customer upgrades, downgrades, and cancellations. Any change in the subscription base is first reflected in the MRR figure, allowing management to monitor customer health frequently.

ARR is calculated by multiplying the current MRR by 12, annualizing this monthly baseline to create a consistent yearly figure. Similarly, the contractual value used to calculate CARR is often broken down into monthly components before being aggregated and annualized. MRR functions as the building block that ensures the accuracy and consistency of the larger annual metrics used for strategic decision-making.

Applying CARR and ARR in Strategic Planning

Management teams use CARR and ARR for distinct but complementary purposes in internal strategic planning and resource allocation. CARR is primarily used as a planning tool for future capacity, signaling confirmed growth and the necessary resources needed to service sold contracts. By tracking the difference between CARR and ARR, leadership can accurately budget for hiring and training new staff in implementation, support, and engineering departments.

The forward-looking nature of CARR allows the organization to set realistic targets for the sales team and plan for capital expenditures to meet confirmed demand. This metric helps in proactive resource provisioning, ensuring that the company’s operational capacity scales efficiently ahead of the revenue recognition. It allows for setting performance targets based on booked revenue, which directly measures the success of the sales function.

ARR is used for operational budgeting, managing the current cost of goods sold (COGS), and calculating retention and churn rates. It reflects the revenue base currently exposed to operational risks. Management uses ARR to calculate metrics like Net Revenue Retention, which measures the growth or contraction of the existing customer base. This focuses on optimizing current operations and controlling expenses based on the active revenue stream.